Move over Macallan! It's Tamdhu time...

Words by Colin Hampden-White

Gordon Dundas of Tamdhu runs through the character of the whisky.

Gordon Dundas of Tamdhu runs through the character of the whisky.

Tamdhu is a whisky worth discovering…

There is a penchant for Scotch whiskies having been matured in Sherry casks and Macallan has been the brand to buy. It is difficult to find whisky which has been completely matured in sherry conditioned casks and not just finished in sherry casks, or blended with casks of other types. There is however a brand with whom you can be sure that the 100% of the whisky has been matured in sherry casks: Tamdhu. If you are a Macallan fan,you are going to love Tamdhu.

More than just sherry casks

Tamdhu believe that a wide range of casks gives them plenty of options to create great whisky. They use a mixture of American oak and European oak sherry casks. Their sherry casks are conditioned in Jerez for the whisky industry and nearly all of those casks are created using American oak. Tamdhu, however, also have casks created using European oak and conditioned for them. What this gives them is the ability not just to create more complex whiskies, but also to bottle single casks matured in both American oak and European oak. This gives us an interesting insight into the differing flavour profiles of these two types of oak.

The Tamdhu range is growing

Tamdhu until recently had a 10 year old in their line up. This has now been upgraded to a 12 year old and the strength increased from 40% to 43%. They have a 15 year old at 46% and they say that in a couple of years, an 18 year old will be added to their line up.

The whiskies are blended from casks of both first fill and second fill American and European oak and the casks are of differing sizes. It is unusual in this day and age to see a whisky brand increasing the age statements of their whisky rather than decreasing them or moving to non age statements. Not that Tamdhu don’t do non age statement whiskies; they have a limited batches of cask strength none age statement whisky, which is now on batch four.

What can one expect when trying Tamdhu?

The 12 year old is rich and remarkably smooth at 43%. One can sip it over time or just as easily add water or a mixer and drink in long. It is versatile; a whisky which is difficult to get bored of. At the other end of the spectrum, the single casks are big bold whiskies, especially the European oak whiskies, which have the typical fruit cake and demerara sugar dominant flavours, with added spices to keep the palate lively and fresh. The American oak single casks still have dried fruit flavours, but they tend to be stone fruits such as apricots and there are core flavours of vanilla and dedicated coconut so often associated with American oak. The two casks I tasted recently, cask 2986 American oak Cask at 56.2% and 2014 European oak cask at 58.9% typified the two flavour profiles and are deeply satisfying whiskies. If your budget can stretch to a single cask bottle though, I’d thoroughly recommend buying one. At a more affordable level, if you are looking for cask strength whisky, then at £65 the limited batch number four is a cracking dram. It can be found at the House of Malt. If you like Macallan, or any whiskies matured in ex Sherry casks, then I think Tamdhu is a whisky you should add to your list, and once you’ve tried it, I think it will stay on your list forever.

I love this limited release batch strength Tamdhu:

Batch Strength (2).png

ABV: 57.8%

Size: 70cl

Buy now for £68

The incredibly drinkable and fruity 12 year old can be found at The Whisky Exchange:

12 year old.png

ABV: 43%

Size: 70cl

Buy it now for £44.99

And my favourite, the single cask American oak offering can be found at The Whisky World:

Single Cask.png

ABV: 56.2%

SIze: 70cl

But it now for £449.90

For more on brilliant whisky that’s blended rather than a single malt, have a read about the great lesser known Johnnie Walker whiskies

Whisky Infused with a Severed Human Toe, Anyone?

Photo courtesy of cultofweird.com

Photo courtesy of cultofweird.com

Words by Helena Nicklin

"You can drink it fast, you can drink it slow. But your lips must touch that gnarly toe."

Believe it or not, in Canada, this is apparently a ‘thing’. It started sometime in the 1920s during prohibition, when a pair of brothers named Louis and Otto got caught in a blizzard while out doing a touch of ‘rum running’ (basically, smuggling illegal booze). Louis’ toe was frozen solid after they returned home, having been caught in water and running through snow. To prevent gangrene setting in, his lovely brother Otto did him the ‘kindest’ favour by chopping off his dead toe cleanly with an axe. Thanks, bro. For some reason, that surely only they will understand, they decided to preserve the toe in a bottle of whiskey to commemorate such a momentous occasion. 

So, why drink a severed toe?

Why indeed? The bottle of whisky was eventually found in a remote cabin used by the brothers when smuggling rum, by Captain Dick Stevenson in 1973. Being a bloke who obviously had spent time in a rugby team, Captain Dick thought the grisly discovery would make a great token for an exclusive cocktail club - one where to join, you would have to drink from the bottle and have your lips touch the toe. *shudders*.

Where can you drink a Sourtoe cocktail?

In Yukon Bar, Dawson City, Canada, the toe still exists and wannabe members of the ‘club’ must still taste a sourtoe cocktail as described above. There is even a ‘toe master’, called Terry Lee, who looks after the toe, tops up the salt that keeps it in condition and lets people pay five dollars to taste a sourtoe cocktail. It’s a huge thing in Dawson City. It’s part of their history. There’s a real emotional connection to the toe. Can you imagine how sad these people were then, when in 2003, a crazy American tourist called Josh came with the express intention to swallow the toe - and then did so? Terry has still not forgiven him for this act of ‘selfishness and destruction’. The only thing that would right the wrong, he said, was for this guy to donate his big toe to the cause. Eeee. 

Terry ‘Toe Master’ Lee at the Yukon Bar in Dawson City.

Terry ‘Toe Master’ Lee at the Yukon Bar in Dawson City.

What happened next?

Josh had not realised exactly what swallowing the toe would do to the community. He felt so terrible that he changed his will to make sure that Dawson City could take his right, big toe upon his death.

But Terry will still not forgive him. Daaaang.

Make your own Sourtoe cocktail

Ingredients:

50cl American Whiskey
1 x toe

Method: 

Pour whisky into a tumbler glass. Add toe. Drink whiskey. Do not swallow toe. Simples. 

Like this? Try Would you invest in Vagina Beer or Could you drink dead people?

From £60 to £100K: The Beauty of Johnnie Walker

Diamond.jpg

Johnnie Walker is a name synonymous with great value, consistency of quality and having a long heritage. Most of us know about the varying colours of the Johnnie Walker family: Red, Black, Green, Gold and Blue, with the last being reassuringly expensive at around £150. But did you know there are Johnnie Walker whiskies which are far more expensive than that? There is even an expression that cost £100,000 + VAT! 

The “Diamond Jubilee” was created in 2012 for the Queen’s Diamond Jubilee which celebrated her 60 years on the throne. The spirit was distilled in 1952 but it’s not only the whisky you are paying for. It comes in a Baccarat decanter on a crystal base, the stopper is Britannia silver and there are diamonds woven into the design. Further even than that, the casks used to marry the whisky are made from oak grown on The Queen’s Sandringham estate. They had been lightly toasted and seasoned with Pedro Ximenez sherry and then grain whisky. 

The cabinet housing the bottle is handmade from Sandringham oak and pine from The Queen’s Balmoral estate. And there is even more: the book which accompanies it is hand bound on the Isle of Skye by Laura West and the writing done in calligraphy by Sally Mangum. Finally, there were only 60 bottles available, plus one for Her Majesty.  

Luckily with Johnnie Walker, one doesn’t normally have to spend £100,000 to get some very fine whisky. Beyond the regular Johnnie Walker colours range there are some super-premium treats at a much more reasonable price point than the Diamond Jubilee expression. Here are a few of my favourites, including one at £60 which will surprise:

Johnnie Walker XR 21 Year Old Blended Whisky

COLIN website images-8.png

A 21 year old blended whisky inspired by the Johnnie Walker Master Blender Alexander Walker II. It is a whisky full of both lemon and orange citrus with a finish of dried fruits soaked in sherry.

ABV: 40%
SIZE: 70cl
Buy it now for £147

Johnnie Walker - Blue Label Ghost & Rare series - Port Ellen

COLIN website images-3.png

A complex blend of many of the usual whiskies that go into Johnnie Walker Blue label, with the added component of some old whisky from Port Ellen distillery, (which closed in 1983) the stocks of which are very rare. This whisky has all the hallmarks of Blue Label, but the salinity and peat come through gently from the Port Ellen.

ABV: 43.8%
Size: 70cl
Buy it now for £253

Johnnie Walker King George V

COLIN website images.png

King George V is a very special edition of blended whisky from Johnnie Walker. Packaged beautifully, it is clearly a super-premium product. It was created to celebrate the Royal Warrant bestowed upon the company by the monarch. This is made with some of Johnnie Walker's rarest stocks, including Cardhu, Lochnagar and even Port Ellen.

ABV: 43%
Size: 70cl
Buy it now for £532

Johnnie Walker - Private Collection 2018, Midnight Blend, 28 yr old

COLIN website images-4.png

A whisky made for drinking after dinner, hence the name Midnight Blend. This is the final edition in the Private collection series, started in 2014. Only 3,888 bottles were created for the world market. It is known to have malt whiskies from the four corners of Scotland giving lots of complexity, mainly butterscotch, caramel and toffee with a touch of spice.

ABV: 42.8%
Size: 70cl
Buy it now for £650

https://amzn.to/3cfT9fo

Johnnie Walker - Blue Label Ghost and Rare Series – Brora

COLIN website images-5.png

This is the first in the Ghost and Rare series and some might say the best. Like the previous Ghost and Rare, which drew upon Port Ellen, Brora distillery in this expression closed its doors in 1983 and is extremely rare and holds cult status amongst whisky aficionados.

ABV: 46%
Size: 70cl
Buy it now for £735

Johnnie Walker - Excelsior - 1947 50 year old Whisky

COLIN website images-2.png

If you really fancy pushing the boat out, then this extremely hard to find whisky is on Amazon today! Distilled in 1947 and released at 50 years old in 1997 it epitomises the brand and its complex blends. Just think, for around 100 times less than the Diamond Jubilee, this whisky was distilled five years earlier, and is still 50 years old.

ABV: 43%
Size: 70cl
Buy it now for £1049

Johnnie Walker aged 18 years old

COLIN website images-2.png

Back down to earth on the price, but not on the flavour, front is this 18 year old blended whisky from Johnnie Walker. It is a great whisky and, for me, gives the best bang for buck in the Johnnie Walker range. It is very smooth and complex and although it says 18 on the label, there are some whiskies in this blend that are quite a bit older. 

ABV: 40%
Size: 40%
Buy it now for £60

For more on Johnnie Walker’s colours get the low down from our previous article and if you are just starting out on your whisky adventure, we have a quick guide to help you on your way.

We Ranked Every Ardbeg Day Special Release By Its Smokiness

Every year since Ardbeg’s iconic Alligator was created for Ardbeg Day, there has been an annual release. Mickey Heads, the distillery manager at Ardbeg, has been there for every single one but he has now announced his retirement. He will still be there for this year’s Ardbeg day release and we wait with anticipation to see what it is. In the meantime, we rank all of the non committee releases so far in reverse order with classic smoky Ardbeg in mind, so from subtle to smoke bomb.

Ardbeg is smoky by nature, so on a 1 to 20 scale of smoky whiskies Ardbeg starts at 10.

First of all, here is the list in order of release:

2011 – Alligator
2012 – Day
2013 – Ardbog
2014 – Auriverdes
2015 – Perpetuum
2016 - Dark Cove
2017 – Kelpie
2018 – Grooves
2019 – Drum 

The Ranking

 No.9 Auriverdes

Ardbeg Auriverdes thethreedrinkers.com

Released in time for the football World Cup in Brazil. Auriverdes means gold and green, which are the colours of the Brazilian flag. Tasting Note: A lighter style of Ardbeg. Easy going sweet vanilla and lemons. There is still smoke, but it is not immediately identifiable as Ardbeg. Muscovado sugar and chocolate appear later in the palate.

ABV: 49.9%
Smoke rating:
10/20 
Buy now for £193

No.8 Drum

ardbeg drum thethreedrinkers.com

In the tradition of Ardbeg being an innovator, this whisky is firstly matured in ex bourbon casks, and extra matured in rum casks. Tasting note: Bonfire wood mixed with lots of ripe bananas and pineapples. Spices on the palate with ginger, liquorice and vanilla.

ABV: 46%
Smoke rating:
12/20
Last auction Price: £70

No.7 Perpetuum

Ardbeg Perpetuum thethreedrinkers.com

Created for the 200th anniversary of Ardbeg distillery, this whisky is a mixture of many cask types intended to give great complexity and harmony. Fresh citrus, toffee and figs head up a smoky background. There is a creamy mouthfeel and lots of dark chocolate.

ABV: 47.4%
Smoke rating: 13/20
But it now for £143

No.6 Grooves

Ardbeg Grooves thethreedrinkers.com

Grooves is so named as the casks used were very well charred ex red wine casks which resulted in deep groves on the inside of the cask resulting in a greater surface area for the spirit to interact with. Tasting note: lots of American oak flavours of vanilla, toffee and popcorn. Salty savoury bacon with chilli, tempered with toffee apples. Old leather-bound books linger in the background.

ABV: 46%
Smoke rating: 14/20
Buy now for £250

No.5 Day

Ardbeg Day thethreedrinkers.com

Using sherry casks in the maturation gives waves of flavour through waves of smoke and peat. Still balanced, this whisky is made for peat heads who also love sherried whisky. Huge mouth feel, big and rich whisky, waves of peat and sherry wash over the palate. This whisky is full, rounded and luscious.

ABV: 56.7%
Smoke rating: 15/20
Buy now for £525

No.4 Kelpie

Ardbeg Kelpie thethreedrinkers.com

This whisky is named after the mythical animals of legend around Islay. Kelpies were shape shifting spirits which usually appeared as horses or ponies. But they were maleficent creatures, and although seeming tame, and particulary friendly to children, once mounted the rider would not be able to dismount and would be dragged to the bottom on the ocean or river and eaten.

ABV: 46%
Smoke rating: 16/20
Buy it now for £190

No.3 Ardbog

Ardbeg Ardbog thethreedrinkers.com

Matured in Manzanilla sherry casks, this whisky has a big smoky punch, but is sweetened by the extra maturation in sherry casks. Undeniably Ardbeg, big and smoky and very dry. Sweetness coming from raisins and there is an underlying rich nutty flavour.

ABV: 52.1%
Smoke rating: 16.5/20
Buy it now for £315

No.2 Dark Cove

Ardbeg Dark Cove thethreedrinkers.com

This is the darkest Ardbeg day release and is a bit of a beast. You’ll either love it or hate it as the smoke is full on and the rich oily iodine nature of the whisky is very in your face. Underlying all that power are  lots of dried fruits such as raisins and dates. Smouldering charcoal and spice with beeswax bring you to smoked meats and salty seaweed.

ABV: 46.5%
Smoke rating: 17/20
But now for £262

No.1 Alligator

Ardbeg Alligator thethreedrinkers.com

At first this expression split the whisky community. It has all the hallmarks of a classic Ardbeg but is also much more. The heavy char of the casks brings the peaty smoke right to the fore with the charred nature of the cask adding even more smokiness. But there is huge complexity too with lots of citrus in the form of grapefruit and lemon, with ginger and orange zest backing that up. There is also sweetness with ginger biscuits and icing sugar and cocoa in the background. Intense smoke runs throughout the dram.

ABV: 51.2%
Smoke rating: 18/20
Buy it now for £472

So why didn’t we go up to 20/20 you ask? Because there are even smokier whiskies than Ardbeg for example Octomore from Bruichladdich distillery, which, depending on the batch is more like a 30/20!

10 Cheap Whiskies That Taste Expensive

Words by Colin Hampden-White

cheap whisky thethreedrinkers.com

There are whiskies out there that don’t cost very much at all and yet they taste like they cost a fortune. So that you don’t have to buy hundreds of bottles to find out which ones they are, we have done all the ‘hard’ work for you. Here’s a list of fabulous whiskies that taste incredible but don’t cost the earth, ordered from light and elegant to rich and smoky:

1: Glenmorangie Original

Glenmorangie Original thethreedrinkers.com

Top of the light and elegant list has to be Glenmorangie Original. This whisky isn’t even listed as a NAS (Non Age Statement) whisky. It is ten years old and 40% Vol. Since 1843 Glenmorangie have been perfecting a light, elegant fruity whisky with lots of orange and vanilla flavours.

Size: UK 700ml // US 750ml
ABV:
40%
Find here:
UK £33.99 // US $52.99

2: Glen Moray Classic

Glen Moray Classic thethreedrinkers.com

Still light and fruity, but with a little more body there is Glen Moray Classic. With flavours of green apples and lemons, it is an easy going satisfying single malt from Speyside at 40% and is our favourite single malt under £30!

Size: UK 700ml // US 750ml
ABV:
40%
Find here:
UK £22.94 // US $34.99

3: Tomintoul

Tomintoul 16 year old thethreedrinkers.com

This whisky is from a distillery hardly anyone will have heard of. Tomintoul is a highland distillery which has an excellent 16 year old single malt at 40%. It is an elegant whisky with plenty of flavour including coffee, boiled sweets, almonds and melted butter with vanilla fudge and cream. This whisky is the best 16 year old at this price on the market.

Size: UK 700ml // US 750ml
ABV:
40%
Find here:
UK £49.94 // US $64.99

4: Hunter Laing

Hunter Laing Highland Journey thethreedrinkers.com

Whiskies sold by the distilleries that make them tend to be more expensive than those released by independent bottlers. Independent companies bottle whiskies which are made all over Scotland, blend their own whiskies and represent incredible value and more often than not taste a great deal more expensive than they cost. My favourite independent blend is from Hunter Laing. Highland Journey is mixture of highland single malt whiskies and is a bold and complex malted blend at a great strength of 46.2%.

Size: 700ml
ABV:
46.2%
Find here:
£32.99

5: Old Pulteney 12

Old Pulteney 12 Year old thethreedrinkers.com

For a rich, but spirit led whisky with lots of saline character from the far north of Scotland, Old Pulteney 12 is a whisky at 40% which punches way above its price tag. It’s more difficult to get your hands on now but you can still pick up a bottle for under £30 and it tastes like double that.

Size: 700ml
ABV:
40%
Find here:
£25.99

6: Glenfiddich 15

Glenfiddich 15 thethreedrinkers.com

For a whisky which has a more sherried character, Glenfiddich 15 is about as good as it gets for bang for buck. It’s a powerful whisky with spices and sweetness all rolled into one. There is a good amount of oak on the palate making the whisky seem older than it is and at 40% for under £45 it is a bargain waiting to be savoured.

Size: 700ml
ABV: 40%
Find here: £47.69

7: Roe and Co

Roe and Co thethreedrinkers.com

Whisky doesn’t have to come from Scotland, and some of the best tasting whiskies come from Ireland. A new whisky to Ireland is Roe and Co. Made with a high proportion of first fill bourbon casks with grain and malt whisky this tastes well above its price tag of a touch under £30. It is non chill filtered to keep more flavour and at 45% it is perfect for mixing!

Size: UK 700ml // US 750ml
ABV:
45%
Find here:
UK £29.88 // US $32.99

8: Johnnie Walker Black Label

Johnnie Walker Black Label Amazon thethreedrinkers.com

Touching on the world of smokey whisky, this whisky is the best value on the list. It is a blend and has a bit of everything. It has an age statement of 12 years old but there are much older whiskies in the blend too so the taste has a hint of aged whiskies to it. There is a mix of sherry and bourbon oak casks blended to give lots of complexity and a hint of smoke as well. A favourite for many in the whisky industry Johnnie Walker Black Label at 40% is as good as it gets. For our UK followers, it can be found for only £20 at the moment (09.11.21) on Amazon.

Size: UK 700ml // US 750ml
ABV: 40%
Find here: UK £26.89 // US $33.99

9: Dailuaine 16

Dailuaine 16 thethreedrinkers.com

For the last two we have some slightly more expensive drams, but they too taste like they should cost well above their price band. The first is Dailuaine 16 from the Flora and Fauna range from Diageo. This whisky is complex and full bodied yet smooth and rich. Lots of dried fruit flavours and very well integrated oaky flavours which one expects to find in whiskies much older than this. It is at 43%. Expect to pay a little under £60 for this delicious dram.

Size: 700ml
ABV: 43%
Find here:
£57.90

10: Ardbeg An Oa

Ardbeg An Oa thethreedrinkers.com

Whiskies from Islay tend to cost a little more. There is a huge following for peated whiskies and finding those whiskies which have lots of smoke, but also rich fruity flavours and spice is tricky and can be expensive. However, An Oa from Ardbeg has all of those characteristics, it still has the punchy smoky flavours one expects from Ardbeg, but there is sweetness and balance to it too and at 46.6% the strength is good too.

Size: UK 700ml // US 750ml
ABV:
46.6%
Find here:
UK £41.99 // US $58.99

*This article was originally published in March 2020 and has now been updated (Sept 2022) to reflect the current change in prices. For more whisky goodness, why not check out The Best Japanese Whiskies to Try or The Best Whiskies in the World

Waterford Distillery - It boils down to soil

In the wine world we are used to the idea of terroir being one of the most important factors in flavour. Similarly, in the world of whisky the idea of place and flavour going together is also logical and widely-known, for example the peaty whiskies from Islay and Sherry bombs from Speyside. However, in today’s world there is even greater emphasis on flavour than address. Peaty whisky doesn’t just come from Islay, it can come from Glasgow or even Australia for that matter, and sherry styles from Taiwan or Japan, for example in the form of Karuizawa.

Within the new world of whisky and flavour, there is one distillery which believes whole heartedly that a large part of the flavour does in fact come from the land on which the barley is grown, and the variety of barley used. Waterford have their barley grown in eighty six farms across Ireland. Each farm has a different soil type and plants different varieties of the grain. To be certain they can show the difference between them, they ferment and distil the barley from the different farms separately.

I’ve been to Waterford and tasted new-make spirit from at least a dozen different farms and varieties, all fermented and distilled the same way, and the difference is remarkable. One of my questions was: why do they do it? There are two simple answers. Firstly, with lots of different new-make spirits, once matured they have a huge palate of flavours to play with when they blend them together to make their whisky. The second reason is to be able to taste the difference if they do single farm bottlings. Waterford are about to launch their inaugural whisky, and within this whisky there is spirit blended from thirty six farms. We await the result with great delight!

The distillery itself is based in Waterford and is not a boutique style distillery. They have two pot stills and the capacity to produce a million litres a year. Their first spirit ran off the stills back on the 9th of December 2015 and production started in January 2016, so by now they certainly have enough casks to create an excellent whisky.

Rare and Independent Whisky Bottlings

rare whisky independent whisky thethreedrinkers.com

For every experience in life, there is a whisky to accompany it. Whether it’s a dram on your porridge or a glass by a fireside late at night, the joy of a good whisky collection is having a choice of a range of bottles to match your mood and the moment.

First published in Club Oenologique.